women's Issues Five Years After Beijing Progress & Drawbacks by HILKKA PIETILA
กกAfter 25 years of international efforts, have gender perspectives and assessments of gender impact been "mainstreamed" as part of national laws, plans and programs? Is action being comprehensively monitored? How will the momentum of the global women's movement be maintained? These questions are explored by Hilkka Pietila, who took part in all five UN women's conferences since 1975. Having been Secretary General of the Finnish UN Association for 17 years, she is now Finland's "Focal Point" for the UN Institute for Training and Research on Women (INSTRAW) and Honorary President of the World Federation of the UN Associations (WFUNA).
The way that the united nations determines whether Member States implement the programmes and resolution they adopt an UN for a is by conducting a review and assessment every five years after a world conference or summit is held. This practice was originally adopted by government in the World Conference of International Women's Year in Mexico City in 1975, and has now been applied to the follow up of all UN world conferences and summits in the 1990s.
REVIEW AND APPRAISAL AS A REGULAR PRACTICE
The experience of developing and reviewing global action plans on women's issues
has a 25 year history (see box). The first three world conferences generated
a massive increase in the interest and participation of governments and non-governmental
organization. By the time of the 1985 Nairobi conference, it became obvious
that organizing a world conference every five years was not feasible in financial
and practical terms. Therefore, no world conference was planned for 1990 for
a five year review and appraisal of the implementation of the 1985 Nairobi agreements.
Instead, a modest administrative procedure was scheduled, but it did not succeed
very well. Without a major intergovernmental event to highligh the outcome,
so few governments were motivated to prepare proper reports that there were
not enough to give g global overview. As a result, it was decided already in
1990 that the next five year review and appraisal should take place at a 1995
fourth world conference on women, which was held in Beijing.
An explicit clause in the Beijing Plat-from states that it consitutes "a
basic group of priority actions that should be carried out during the next five
years," meaning that the years 2000 was the time for a five year review
and appraisal. Furthermore, the exercise in 2000 was to cover a longer period,
back to 1975. The Mexico World Plan of Action had been extended in the 1985
Nairobi conference, which also adopted the Forward-looking Strategies in order
the speed up and strengthen the implementation of earlier plans through the
year 2000. Thus, all UN programs for advancement and empowerment of women adopted
by the governments in the past 25 years were to expire in 2000.
In June 1998 the UN Ceneral Assembly decided to convene not a world conference
but the 23rd UN General Assembly Special Session (UNGASS), entitled "Women
2000: Gender Equality, Development and Peace for the Twenty-first Century"
(called UNGASS Women 2000 or Beijing 5 for brevity). The General Assembly has
chosen special sessions as the forum for other five year world conference reviews
in the 1990s Rio+5 for the UN Conference on the Environment UNCED; Cairo + 5
for the International Conference on Population and Development (ICPD); Cairo+5
for the ICPD; and Copenhagen + 5 for the World Summit on Social Development
(WSSD).
The Special Session on women's issues (Beijing+5) was held in New York June
5-9,2000. It was attended by 2300 delegates from 178 member states and more
than 1000 accredited NGOs represented by 2000 delegates. In addition, about
1000 NGO participants attended parallel events organized by a special committee
of the Conference of NGOs (CONGO) and the US Host Committee at the US Customs
House in lower Manhattan. Only five NGOs were given the opportunity to address
the GA Special Session among the 207 speakers altogether.
PROGRESS AND DRAWBACKS
The UN sent a broad questionnaire to member governments to report about their
policies and actions to implement the Beijing PFA. Before UNGASS began, 146
to 188 Member States responded to the questionnaire. These replies were summarized
in a report, published in January 2000, which is an excellent source of information
on achievement at the official level (United Nation, 2000a).
Several other reports facilitated the review and assessment. Every five years
since 1984 the UN system has jointly produced a world survey on the role of
women in development. The surveys are multisectoral and interdisciplinary in
scope, and have provided timely and important background resources for the five
year review and assessments of successive world conferences on women. In 1999
the fourth survey in the series was published with a focus on "globalization,
gender and work" (United Nations, 1999b). This survey is based on research,
knowledge and data produced by appropriate UN organizations and agencies, not
relying on information given by governments only.
Two other reports which compiled and analyzed plenty of statistical information
also came out in time for the Special Session. One was UNIFEM's new biennial
report titled "Progress of the World's Women 2000" which covers from
the mid 1980s to the late 1990s, i. E. From the Nairobi Conference to the GA
Special Session 2000 (UNIFEM, 2000b). The second report is "The World's
Women 2000: Trends and Statistics" published by the UN Statistics Division
(United Nations, 2000b), which updates data and analyses from the 1991 and 1995
editions.
These four new UN reports provide an abundance of information on the situation
of the world's women today and the progress achieved in recent decades. They
also present many criteria and indicators, which have been in short supply until
lately. The information available on women in the UN sources
WOMEN NEED PEACE, AND PEACE NEEDS WOMEN
Women from around the world have urged the UN Security Council to take stronger
action to protect women and girls during conflicts and ensure women's full participation
in peace negotiation and peacebuilding. These calls came on 24-25 October when
the Security Council held its first ever debate on women's experiences in war
and its aftermath. Women and children account for over three quarters of the
40 million people displaced worldwide, mainly due to conflicts.
"Without international action, women caught in conflicts will be stranded
in a vast security void," said Noeleen Heyzer, Executive Directore of the
UNDP administered UN Development Fund for Women (UNIFEM). "And without
their full participation in peace processes, there will be no justice or sustainable
development." She said the Security Council was demonstrating an unprecedented
willingness to bear witness to women's experiences of war, and described the
Council sessions as an important step towards increasing protection and fully
prosecuting war crimes such as rape, sexual exploitation, torture and mutilation.
Opening the debate, UN Secretary General Kofi Annan said, "For generations,
women have served as peace educators, both in their families and in their societies,"
and have "proved instrumental in building bridges rather than walls."
Anwarul Karim Chowdhury of Bangladesh called on the Council to send a strong
message that, "Women need peace, and more importantly, peace needs women."
During the debate, representatives of more than 40 countries supported strengthening
protection for women and their role in peacemaking and peacebuilding.
"If the Security Council wants peace, they must seek it where it is found,"
said Dr. Inonge Mbikusita Lewanika of the Organization of African Unity's Women's
Committee on Peace and Development. She cited examples of women's role in promoting
peace in conflicts in Mali, Mozambique, Somalia, South Africa, Sudan and Uganda.
Women's direct participation at the peace table is the only guarantee that women's
needs and interests will be a part of peace agreements, said Luz Mendez, General
Coordinator of the National Union of Guatemalan Women, Who participated in her
country's 1996 peace negotiations. "As the result of the efforts of women,
the Guatemalan Peace Agreements include specific is very broad and qualitatively
high level if only the governments, women researchers and activists would make
full use of it. At the same time, there are some shortfalls in the data. For
example, information on violence against women is still scattered and comparative
statistics on it are rare, because this issues is so sensitive and traditionally
largely silenced. A continuing problem is that national statistical offices
still don't disaggregate their information adequately, despite repeated UN requests
for this since the 1970s. "
ALTERNATIVE REPORTS FROM PEOPLE AND NGOS
This time there was double checking of governments implementation of the programmes
for advancement and empowerment of women. In addition to the obligation of Member
States to report periodically to the UN, there are active NGOs and women's groups
in most member countries which follow up on these issues more closely than the
UN ever can. An NGO representative at Beijing put it this way:
For the NGOs the Beijing PFA is the culmination of women's struggles for justice
in their diverse contexts around the world and on embodiment of their vision
and hopes for the society that recognizes women'' rights as human rights, and
not just an international documents to pay lip service to, as it is to many
political delegates.
The NGO women attending the meeting of the Preparatory Committee for UNGASS
in March 1999 initiated the idea of preparing alternative reports on the implementation
of the PFA. The NGOs used the same questionnaire which was sent to governments
by the UN. The NGO reports commented on the reports of their governments, made
their own assessment of implementation in their countries, recorded their own
implementation activities, and proposed additional actions for forthcoming years.
Altogether 116 alternative reports were received. Of these 80 were national
reports from 57 countries (several reports from some countries), 15 were regional
reports, and 14 wree theme reports. The individual reports were compiled into
regional reports, and these were then summarized into an "NGO Alternative
Global Report" (CONGO, 2000). Before the opening of the Special Session,
this report and highlights of regional reports were given to its President,
Theo Ben-Gurirab (Namibia).
The most important function in preparing alternative reports was to mobilize
women in countries all over the world to study the reports of their governments
and criticize and comment on them at home. The work done and the ideas collected
in this process also provided NGO women the necessary substance and competence
for commenting on the official draft Outcome Document prepared for the Special
Session. Their country level work led to the creation of the Coalition in Support
of the Beijing Platform for Action, comprising 171 NGOs and network from every
region of the world.
During the March 2000 Preparatory Committee for UNGASS, the Coalition presented
a paper giving a "package" of proposed amendments, additions and deletions
to the draft Outcome Document of the conference. The Coalition paper was the
first to be introduced and negotiated directly with government delegations.
The next stage was NGO lobbying operations, adopting the same strategies as
in earlier UN conferences. NGOs used all possible occasions to present the Coalitions
proposals, monitor government negotiations on official draft documents and prepare
more suggestions and amendments. The lobbying activities naturally continued
internsively until the last sessions of the negotiating groups during the Special
Session.
Altogether the official and the non-governmental reports on implementation of
the PFA contain a huge amount of information and experience to be analysed and
used to facilitate further work in the advancement and empowerment of women.
Unfortunately, research groups in the UN system and at country levels probably
have very limited financing and other resources for doing this kind of work.
In fact, it is even rare for such political and women researchers to be included
in UN system reports and documentation.
INTERNET AS A CHANNEL FOR WOMEN'S VOICES
For some years, the United Nations Internet websites have included a gateway
to global information on women called Women Watch. In connection with the Beijing+5
review, the UN system itself introduced another way for individuals from all
over the world to communicate their views, experiences and suggestions directly
to the intergovernmental system. This was done by opening, on the Women Watch
Internet pages, global online working groups on implementation of the 12 critical
areas of concern of the Beijing PFA. Concerned men and women everywhere were
invited to participate in these electronic groups. The new channel was jointly
facilitated by the three UN bodies concerned with women the UN Division for
Advancement of Women, UNIFEM and INSTRAW.
This innovative use of the Internet was a very successful and exciting exercise
in communication. It could even be called a global democracy experiment. Most
of the lists were open for about six weeks in latter 1999, but the list on "End
violence against women" lasted 16 months from October 1998 to February
2000. It culminated in a great live global video conference on "A World
Free of Violence against Women" in the General Assembly Hall at the UN
on International Women's Day 1999. Altogether 10000 individuals from over 120
countries subscribed to these virtual working groups, and more than 1000 contributions
were posted. Many others had one to one exchanges that contributed to the overall
dialogue but were not seen on the screen.
This was the first time that this kind of follow up exercise was provided for
the review of any UN world conference or summit meeting. One may ask, was this
just another privilege for women of the global North? But the participation
spread surprisingly evenly, with 45 per cent from the South and 52 per cent
from the North, though exact distribution is difficult to get since most e-mail
addresses don't indicate country of origin. By comparison, only 19 per cent
of Internet users in general are outside Europe and North America. In some of
the working groups, for example on environment and decision making, more than
half of the contributions came from the South. On average more than half of
the contributors were from NGOs. Between 13 and 30 per cent of the participants
were from governments, 24 per cent were academic people, and the lowest group
was from intergovernmental organizations at 7 per cent (United Nations, 2000c).
Furthermore, the Internet working groups provided an unparalleled new opportunity
for civil society to participate directly inter intergovernmental process. One
might like to ask, what was the weight and importance of 1000 Internet interventions
by NGO and civil society directly to the UN bodies, compared with only five
statements allotted to the NGO representatives in the formal plenary of UNGASS?
All material from this Internet exchange is available in the archives of Women
Watch. It is a huge repository of case examples, failures and successes, experiences
and reviews which are more authentic and personal than the governmental or even
the NGO reports as such. Will researchers or relevant UN bodies analyze and
benefit from it for its interest either as substance or as an experimental new
option for the use of information technology? The Women Watch website contains
the reports of each on-line working group at
http://www.un.org/womenwatch/forum.
UNGASS HARD WORK AND MEAGER RESULTS
The Beijing Platform for Action is so rich and progressive, and its recomment-dations
for policies and actions so concrete and practical, that it is apt to create
overwhelming hopes and expectations. The vision about forthcoming improvements
and progress in women's lives causes women to expect a lot from their governments.
They also motivate, encourage and mobilize women to struggle and work by themselves.
The review and assessment not only summarizes achievements, but also reveals
shortcomings and drawbacks, which cause disapointment and frustration.
Since Beijing, some new trends and macro-processes have gained momentum more
than was foreseen five years ago. The expansion and further liberalization of
international trade and the accelerating globalization of economic structures
have produced consequences of unexpected dimensions. There have been repercussion
on the policies of industrialized countries regarding the financing of development
cooperation and allocations to UN agencies. The decline of allocations from
the North has seriously hampered developing countries and the UN in their implementation
of programmes adopted by the world conferences.
The NGO Alternative Global Report identifies policies that have aggravated "feminization
of poverty". There include the privatization of public services, trade
liberalization, deregulation of economies, withdrawal of subsidies, downsizing
of governments, substitution of food production by cash crops, and failure to
monitor and regulate the inflow of foreign capital and enterprises. The Report
also draws attentions to the low pay and insecurity of women's jobs, and it
claims that "government policies of the last five years have not only failed
too address this issue, but some policy decisions have actually exacerbated
the situation."
Another major problem is the fatal and devastating plague of constantly increasing
HIV/AIDS infections, expecially in Africa, but spreading in all continents.
Originally it appeared more often among men, but in recent years has rapidly
increased among women and girls due to several reasons, including traditional
customs and beliefs. In Africa the prevalence of HIV infection among women is
now higher than among men, with young women under age 25 constituting the group
most at risk. Ninety five per cent of people with HIV live in developing countries,
whose resources and other prerequisites for effective health policies are already
insufficient and strained. In addition, the African regional alternative report
claims that Africa now is worse off than it was five years ago in terms of HIV
and AIDS, as well as armed conflicts which render women more vulnerable to violence.
The shadow of these trends permeated the atmosphere of the review and appraisal
process, especially in the minds of women from the global South. The realities
of their lives contradicted the expectations and hopes created by the Beijing
Conference and the adoption of the PFA five years before. "We cannot speak
about the Beijing plus five, for us it is a Beijing minus five, many Southern
women felt, while women in the economically prospering North do not adequately
realize the connections between the policies of their governments and the fate
of the South. "
The same forces which in Beijing had fought fiercely against progress and for
reversing the achievements made in Cairo and other pre-Beijing world conferences
have not given up. They were active again both during the Preparatory Committee
meeting in March and Special Session in June. Catholic fundamentalists from
various countries with their allies from some Islamic countries managed to slow
down and even stall the negotiation process to the extent that at times it felt
as if the whole conference would fail. The question was raised, whether it would
be better not to have any outcome document at all than to adopt a very bad paper
diluting even the PFA text?
As a result, government delegates as well as NGO observers spent long nights
struggling through irrelevant arguments and mere filibuster by certain government
representatives. The Special Session ran past its closing time by more than
24 hours. Finally the five year review and assessment of the implementation
of the Beijing PFA was concluded a very important outcome as such but few steps
forward were made.
The outcome document, containing the Political Declaration and the document
on "Further actions and initiatives to implement the Beijing Declaration
and Platform for Action," was unanimously adopted in the final plenary
(United Nations, 2000e). There governments reaffirmed their commitments to the
goals and objectives of the Beijing Declaration and Platform for Action and
pledged further action to ensure it full and accelerated implementation. This
decision implies that the Beijing Declaration and Platform for Action is extended
for five more years, until 2005, as the single valid intergovernmental programme
for advancement and empowerment of women in these years.
ACHIEVEMENTS, OBSTACLES AND FURTHER ACTIONS
Two hundred paragraphs of recommendations to be implemented in forthcoming five
years are contained in the final outcome document of the Special Session. They
are given its section on "Actions and initiatives to overcome obstacles
and to achieve the full and accelerated implementation of the Beijing PFA."
In comparison with the language of the Beijing PFA, however, this document is
weak and incoherent. It is like a patchwork, hundreds of detailed suggestions
and recommendations follow each other without systematic structure and priorities.
Obviously this is due to the extremely difficult atmosphere, the lack of time,
and the lack of unity among Member States at the Special Session. Little more
than a year was allocated for its preparation, while the preparations for a
world conference usually take three to four years.
The first thing for governments to do after the Beijing 1995 conference was
to translate the PFA into the national language in countries where none of the
official languages of the UN (English, French, Russian, Spanish, Chinese and
Arabic) is generally spoken. There are no statistics about this task, but we
heard fairly soon after the Beijing Conference that PFA was translated in some
big countries into several native languages (six languages in India, for example),
that women in East African villages were studying PFA ion the regional language
Swahili, that the PFA was issues in more "reader friendly" language
in English speaking Canada, etc.
The second task given to governments in the PFA was to prepare National Action
Plans for implementation of the PFA in each country within a year, latest by
the end of 1996. The PFA itself set the instructions and deadline for this task,
one of its rare time bound targets. Not all countries were able to produce it
in that period. A survey in September 1997, two years after Beijing, showed
that 112 countries had an action plan finalized and 21 more had a draft a total
of 133 countries or 70 per cent of the 189 countries which participated in Beijing.
The UN Secretariat reports having received national action plans only from 116
Member States, two observer states, and five regional or subregional groups,
which makes 123 action plans altogether.
Development is three out of the 12 critical areas of concern in the PFA call
for some discussion:
Education and training is the filed where signs of progress are very clear.
School enrolment in general has increased in almost all regions, and girls enrolment
in many countries more than boys, thus the inequality gap is declining. At the
secondary level many countries showed great increases in female enrolment in
1995-1997 (UNIFEM, 2000a). Feminization of tertiary level education is spreading
in many countries, with increasing numbers of women attending colleges and universities
and doing longer studies than men. The goals were to close the gender gap in
primary and secondary education and reduce the women's illiteracy by half from
the level of 1990 by 2005. Another general target is to ensure free compulsory
and universal primary education for all, both girls and boys and improve the
adult literacy by 50 per cent by 2015.
Violence against women has been criminalized almost everywhere, but is still
increasing both at home and in new types of armed conflicts. The Special Session
condemned "honour killings" and forced marriages for the first time
in an international consensus document. Stronger measures were called for to
eliminate "dowry related violence" and female genital mutilation,
and to legislate against domestic violence in general, including marital rape
and sexual abuse of women and girls. It was confirmed that violence against
women and girls is a human rights issue, and thus the various forms of violence
against women are human rights violations. There was also agreement to work
towards the elimination of commercial sexual exploitation, as well as economic
exploitation, including trafficking in women and children and female infanticide.
Women and economy. Women's participation in paid work has risen in almost all
regions of the world, and it has also spearheaded overall employment growth
in recent years. Everywhere except. Africa, women's employment has grown substantially
faster than men's since 1980 but usually under conditions inferior to those
associated with men's employment (United Nations, 1999b). As women's employment
rises, problems in reconciling employment and family responsibilities are increasingly
felt, due to lack of supportive services and low participation of men in household
chores.
OTHER RESULTS:
MAINSTREAMING MISSING
Furthermore, some important results and outcomes achieved in these years are
not recorded in the outcome document.
First, gender awareness has improved. The World Survey on the Role of Women
in Development considers it a great achievement that "the conferences and
summits of the 1990s and their five yearly reviews were crucial in raising gender
awareness in the world. The Survey notes that these events "had the cumulative
effect of placing gender at the centre of international discourse on policymaking
relating to environment, population, human rights, food security and social
development" (United Nations, 1999b)
Second, the improvement of the status of women in the UN Secretariat is not
recorded in the review and appraisal documents, though clear targets were set
for it in the PFA. Very rapid improvement has taken place between 1989 and 1999;
the percentage of women in the UN Secretariat who hold senior and decision making
positions increased fivefold at D-1 level (from 6.4 per cent to 34.3 per cent)
and almost tripled at D-2 level (from 8.2 per cent to 23.2 per cent). The great
improvement is due to very radical instructions given by the secretary General
in 1993 for "exceptional measures to recruit, promote and deploy women
in the shortest possible time", and to the Strategic Plan of Action for
Improvement of the Status of WOMEN IN THE Secretariat (1995-2000) introduced
in 1994. The latest target is to achieve parity 50/50 by the year 2000.
Early stage in his times in office, Sec-retary General Kofi Annan established
two important two important positions which enhance his cabinet's expertise
in gender related issues and its representation of women. In January 1997 he
appointed Angela E. V. King, an experienced UN veteran from Jamaica, as Assistant
Secretary General and Special Adviser to the Sec retary-General on Gender Issues
and the Advancement of Women. In early 1998, a new post of Deputy Secretary
General was established as the highest position next to the Secretary General,
and which is understood to be held by a woman as long as the SG is a man. The
Secretary General appointed Ms. Louise Frechette from Canada as the first one
to hold this post.
These recent developments are worth-while mentioning, since many people believe
that the UN itself is not very good in implementing recommendations adopted
by Member States. (A/54/403,27 Sept. 1999). The progress made in 1990s regarding
the status of women in the Secretariat probably beats any administration in
the Member States.
Third, the outcome document definitely should have dealt with (but aid not)
a very important core issue which penetrates the whole PFA: the main streaming
of a gender perspective in all policies and actions of Member States and the
UN system. The recommendation for "an active and visible policy of mainstreaming
a gender perspective into all policies and programmes and an analysis of its
effects on women and men, respectively" is emphasized and repeated in connection
with almost everyone of the twelve critical areas of concern in the PFA.
In a meeting of the UN Economic and Social Councial (ECOSOC) two years after
Beijing, governments approved the "ECONSOC Agreed Conclusions" (ECOSOC
1997/2). In this agreement, governments placed an obligation on the UN system
to apply gender mainstreaming throughout the system. In a way, these conclusions
also recognize that gender mainstreaming is an element in, and a means to integrate
and coordinate, all the work of the UN system in this respect.
Also the report of the Secretary General on Review and Appraisal recalls that
"Cender analysis was established as a basic requirement for mainstreaming
strategy. The current situation of women and men in relation to different issues
problems and the impact of planned policies, legislation, and projects and programmes
on women and men respectively and on the relations between them should be analysed
before any decisions are made. Gender analysis should go beyond cataloguing
differences to identifying inequalities and assessing relationships between
women and men Mainstreaming also requires transformative change." (United
Nations, 2000)
In the Outcome Document from UNGASS, however, there is hardly anything about
mainstreaming and only a couple of passing references to gender impact assessment.
The only achievement mentioned is that "within the UN system much progress
has been made in the mainstreaming of a gender perspective" (para 18) and
that "progress has also bee make to integrate the human rights of women
and mainstream a gender perspective into the UN system, including into the work
of the Office of the High Commissioner on Human Rights and the Commission on
Human Rights" (para 20)
Fortunately in the Political Declaration of the Special Session the governments
do.
"Reaffirm the importance of mainstreaming a gender perspective in the process
of implementing the outcome of other major United Nations conferences and Summits
and the need for a coordinated follow up to all major conferences and Summits
by Governments, regional organizations, and all of the bodies and organizations
of the UN system within their respective mandates. (para 7).
In fact, gender mainstreaming and gender impact assessment are the most far
reaching obligations set by the PFA. Naturally, they apply to each and every
one of the Member States within their countries, since they adopted it unanimously
for themselves in Beijing in 1995 as he core requirement of the Platform of
Action. Enforcement of these obligations by making them part of the law in Member
States would create an automatic mechanism for gender mainstreaming and equality
which operates in all legislation and policymaking in the future. On this issue,
implementation absolutely needs to be enhanced in the years to come.
GLOBAL WOMEN'S MOVEMENT BEING CREATED
Within the decades since the 1970s the mobilization of women has taken place
on a world scale and with an accelerating pace, and a world wide women's movement
has been born. The NGO Tribune in Mexico City already in 1975 was described
as the "largest consciousness raising session ever held". The NGO
Forum in Nairobi 1985 has been referred to as the "birth of global feminism"
(UN, 2000d). The NGO Alternative Global Report states that "as we moved
beyond the 1980s, it became clear that what we had created was a global women's
movement and what we had set in motion was nothing less than a revolution"
(CONGO, 2000).
The global conferences of the 1990s were pivotal in the development of a politically
able and astute global women's movement. "Strengthened by the three women's
world conferences of 1975, 1980, and 1985, women moved to the forefront in these
conferences (in the 1990s), claiming a space and voice in the resulting policies.
These conferences served as training grounds for a new leadership by brining
hundreds of women into the public policy process and resulting, in many countries,
in a critical mass of women with political clout" (CONGO, 2000).
From the beginning, the world conferences in the 1990s were seen as constituting
a global agenda for development. The governments and the UN have adopted the
method of review and appraisal for an integrated and coordinated implementation
of, and follow up to, the major United Nations conferences and summits. The
next stage will be Rio+10, Vienna+10, Cairo+10, Copen hagen+10, Vienna+10, Cairo+10,
Copen hagen+10 (etc). Processes, following the completion of the five year reviews.
The follow up of the Beijing Conference often seems to be lumped together with
all the major conferences and summits, though its purpose and nature (and the
earlier women's conferences as well) were basically different from other world
conferences. The women's conferences did not deal with a particular theme, but
brought to the global agenda the interests and aspirations of women which have
not been heard equally before.
The particular nature and importance of the advancement of women was understood
in the UN system when the series of world conferences on environment, human
rights, population and social development, the so called global agenda, was
planned in the beginning of the 1970s. The Secretary General's introduction
to the UN Blue Book on Advancement of Women stresses that "the goals they
[the other world conferences] seek are all dependent upon the advancement of
women" (United Nations, 1995b, para, 220).
FUTURE WORLD CONFERENCES ON WOMEN WILL THERE BE ANY?
To continue the progress of the global women's movement and maintain momentum
in the advancement and empowerment of women, a strong demand for holding in
2005 a new world conference on women has been expressed by the NGO community.
This was voiced at Beijing+5 preparatory meetings of the Commission on the Status
of Women in March 2000. This call also received broad support from the global
NGO community gathered during the UNGASS in June 2000.
However, what the governments agreed to in the Political Declaration adopted
in the UNGASS was less specific. Its paragraph 9 agrees
"to regularly assess further implementation of the Beijing Platform for
Action, with the view to brining together all parties involved in 2005 to assess
progress and consider new initiatives, appropriate, 10 years after the adoption
of the Beijing Plat-from for Action and 20 years after the adoption of the Nairobi
Forward looking Strategies".
What the NGOs are asking is only that the governments specify the event in 2005
to become a world conference of a particular kind. It would not be a replica
of the Beijing, but should comprehensively review and assess how gender concerns
are mainstreamed in the whole process of integrated implementation of the other
major United Nations conferences and summits. The central aims of such an overarching
"meat" world conference in 2005 would be to:
Review and appraise progress in the years 1975-2005
Develop goals and strategies to meet the needs of women arising from new global
trends and enhance women's full participation in shaping the policies for integrated
and coordinated implementation of the global agenda for development in the 21st
Century.
In its substantial session in summer 2000, ECOSOC made the first "Assessment
of the progress made within the United Nations system, through the conference
reviews, in the promotion of an integrated and coordinated implementation of
and follow up to major United Nations conferences and summits in the economic,
social and related fields". That assessment gives new grounds for considering
what kind of major conference "on women" could best analyze the mainstreaming
of a gender perspective in the whole process of the implementation of the global
agenda. Such analyses were clearly not done in the series of five year reviews
of the 1990s world conferences just conclude. Even the review of the implementation
of the Beijing PFA neglected to cover mainstreaming.
Concerning the outcome of the Beijing+5 process as such, it became obvious that
a GA special session would not be the effective mode of event to bring about
new plans and strategies for continuing the process in the future. Another kind
of a procedure is needed in order to achieve two goals: system wide review and
appraisal of women's empowerment and gender mainstreaming, for guaranteeing
the continuation and momentum of the process; and providing a wide NGO Forum
for the world's women to bring their views and aspirations into the proceedings
of the global agenda in the future.
References
CONGO, 2000. Beijing Plus Five. NGO Alternative Global Report to the UNGASS
5 Years after Beijing, June 5-9. 2000. New York. UNFPA, 2000. The State of World
Population 2000: Lives Together, Worlds Apart. New York, 2000.
UNIFEM, 2000a. Targets and Indicators. Selection from Progress of the World's
Women. New York.
2000b. Progress of the World's Women. A New Biennial Report. New York.
United Nations and the Advancement of Women 1945-1995. The United Nations Blue
Book Series, vol. VI. New York 1995.
United Nations, 1999a. Improvement of the status of women in the Secretariat.
Report of the Secretary General. A/54/403.27 September 1999.
1999b, 1999 World Survey on the Role of Women in Development; Globalization,
Gender and Work. General Assembly, A/54/227.
2000a. Review and appraisal of the implementation of the Beijing Platform for
Action. Report of the Secretary General. E/CN.6/2000/PC/2.
Statistical Division. 2000b. The World's Women 2000: Trends and Statistics.
New York.
2000c. Summary of the Women Watch Online Working Groups on the 12 Gritical Areas
of Concern.
E/CN.6/2000/PC/CRP.1
2000d. Women 2000. Information folder published by DPI, including i. W. Article:
Elisabeth Ruziska Dempasey and Abigail Loreguard Kasmally; The Four Global Women's
Conferences 1975-1995. Historical Perspective.
2000c. Political Declaration and Further actions and initiatives to implement
the Beijing Declaration and Platform for Action. "A/S-23/10/Rev.1